Oil-by-rail industry in North America begins 2014 with another spectacular crash

CN Rail derailment in northern New Brunswick on Jan 7, 2014, image from Facebook

North America’s frenzied oil-by-rail industry began the new year in the same way it ended the old one—with a spectacular derailment and fire of oil train cars on the outskirts of a small community. It’s the latest calamity by an industry growing at a pace that should frighten anyone concerned with public safety and the world’s warming climate.

Concern is further underlined by a new derailment--seven cars in a 152-car coal train derailed in the center of the Vancouver region on Jan. 11. Nearby is a CP Rail route that handles daily shipments of oil to a refinery on the shore of Vancouver harbor.

The latest oil train derailment took place near the town of Plaster Rock in northern New Brunswick along the main CN Rail line that connects the ocean ports of Halifax, Nova Scotia and Saint John, New Brunswick to Montreal and points west. In the early evening of January 7, 19 cars and a rear locomotive in a mixed-cargo, 122-car CN train derailed. Five of the cars contained crude oil and four were carrying liquefied petroleum gas (propane or butane).

Two hundred people were ordered to immediately evacuate their homes in the area. It was three days before they were able to return home, though some still don't have permission to do so. Traffic along the rail line has resumed.

Details of how many of the cars caught fire are still sketchy. At least one oil wagon, two propane wagons and the locomotive caught fire. The two burning propane wagons and a third one were deliberately blown up on Jan 10 to expedite the clean up and a return to train traffic. Without the controlled explosions, the propane cars would have burned for days longer. A special team from Louisiana was called in to perform the detonations.

According to CN, there were 45 cars carrying dangerous chemicals in the train. Plaster Rock is 30 km east of the Trans Canada Highway and the nearby international border with the U.S. state of Maine. There were no immediate injuries.

The oil and propane cars were loaded in western Canada and destined for the Irving Oil refinery in Saint John. Irving is a family-owned, industrial conglomerate that dominates the economy of Atlantic Canada and has a large presence in northern New England. Its oil division was the contractor that brought the oil train through Lac Mégantic, Quebec on July 6 last year. That derailment killed 47 people, obliterated the center of the town and spilled millions of liters of oil into the adjacent lake and river system.

Residents in and around Plaster Rock saw the night sky light when the derailment happened. Andrew Simpson told CBC, “We were playing cards at my uncle’s, the table rumbled, we looked out, and the window was orange. Everything was on fire across the road.”

Controlled detonation of a derailed propane car at Plaster Rock New Brunswick, January 10. Screenshot from CBC video. 

The derailment occurred close to the Tobique River, a major tributary of the St. John River, the largest in Atlantic Canada. It is not reported whether any oil has escaped into the river system.

The first responders to the scene were the members of Plaster Rock’s volunteer fire department. As the CBC reported, in an understatement, “they were not ready for this”. By the next morning, the town was overrun with out-of-town emergency equipment and personnel from CN and Irving Oil and from nearby jurisdictions. But the fire was too intense to fight. CBC news reported one day later, “Residents, railway officials and first responders can only wait, watch and hope for the best.”

Volunteer firefighter Darren Burgoyne was among the first on the scene. He said he and his colleagues did not know what they were dealing with. He told CBC, “The scary part for me was the huge plume of black smoke that was blowing right towards… the village. But it was more or less bypassing us … and of course our fear was we didn’t know if it was toxic or not.”

This accident follows by nine days an oil train derailment outside the town of Casselton, North Dakota. There, 20 cars of a 104-car unit oil train derailed and exploded in spectacular fireballs that were captured on amateur film by nearby residents.

Reassuring words from industry and government

Among the CN personnel soon on the scene at Plaster Rock was company CEO, Claude Mongeau. He held a press conference the morning after the accident and began by offering an apology.

Read More:

More in Commentary

Why BC’s future should be a geothermal one. Photo by Lydur Skulason via Flick

Why BC’s future should be a geothermal one

If BC leaders took a trip to Reykjavik in Iceland, they could learn how the city benefits from the largest district heating system in the world.
Photo of oil pumps. Photo by CGP Grey

Let’s cut government fossil fuel subsidies and free up billions for more productive investment

With the US and China developing their own fully integrated natural gas systems, demand for BC gas is plummeting, as are global prices.

Charles Manson & marriage: an ungodly duo

The internet erupted after learning Charles Manson, 80, was granted a license to marry 26-year-old Afton Elaine Burton, who prefers the name “Star,” because Manson says she's a "Star in the...
Due to an unmanageable stream of spam, we have disabled commenting until further notice. Go to @VanObserver to comment on Twitter or VancouverObserver on Facebook to join the conversation about this article.

PIPELINES ARE SAFER

Pipeline transportation of oil and such is well over 100 times safer than any other means, yet the activists demand that they not be built.  When I see all these activists living in unheated homes, walking and riding bicycles to wherever they need to go, not buying any food that has been transported by use of hydrocarbon fuels etc. then I'll realize they aren't hypocrites.  What we see now with all the big climate love-ins held yearly at exotic resorts with these people flying in big jets, (often even private ones) and spending like royalty, it's obvious that they are in it for personal selfish reasons. 

 

Roger Annis asks "What will

Roger Annis asks "What will it take to put an end to the danger of oil-by-rail...".  Well it seems the answer is pretty obvious, pipelines.  By everyone except Mulcair, and he seems to think rail is safe?  And he wants to run Canada!

I live in Kamloops and can see the CPR mainline from my house.  Over the past 2 or 3 years we have noticed a marked increase in tank cars on the CPR line.  And that is also the case with the CNR line.  On average, there are 25 to 30 trains going through Kamloops on the CP line, and 20 to 25 on the CN line.  Throw in a potential half dozen more trains a day loaded with petroleum products bound for Mayor Moonbeams city, and life could get a bit uncomfortable.  Don't forget that both the CP and the CP travel down the Thompson and Fraser rivers on their way to the coast.  Drive the Fraser Canyon sometime and see just how treacherous the terrain is that these trains travel on.  And people don't want pipelines?

Last fall I was at Granville Island Market and saw a couple of vehicles that had bumper stickers on them that read: "Stop Pipelines", or something to that effect.  What planet do the drivers of these gas burning cars (they weren't electric cars) live on?  They don't want petroleum moved to their city, but they want the gas and oil that is needed to operate their cars.

Bizzare!  And so typical of so many people in the Lower Mainland.

hey VO - wow - almost a factual argument - still casting aspersions with adjectives at everything you do not agree with - but at east this article does not insert explosion as the go to word for every derailment and fire -

where the facts come off the rails - juxtaposing that every train derailment or runaway is the same as what happened in one particular incident as if they were all the same -

that the Prince Rupert Santa train cancellation had to do with hydrocarbon transport - when indeed it may have been the volume of containers from the port running east by rail - or simply as stated the lapse of proactive administrative action -

train movement is dependent on many factors working in concert - wheels turning - rails being in good shape - rail beds not suffering environmental degradation due to normal or unusual environment activity - tracks being clear of debris and traffic up to next end point -

just from that one photograph of the NB incident i see a siding - this indicates to my limited knowledge that some sort of activity other than go forward was being conducted - which brings a human element to the  orchestra -- what does the TSB say about the incident - ??