Vancouver's arts and culture bleeding out in “steady migration", warn city creatives

Underneath the vibrant, diverse surface of a thriving arts and culture scene, Vancouver faces a loss of its brightest painters, dancers, designers, makers and performers to greener pastures. VO investigates how rising real estate prices are crunching our city's artists.

Vancouver arts and culture bleeding out of Vancouver. What will artists do? Photos by David P. Ball

One of Vancouver's most creative and unique spaces is so obscure it takes a Youtube video to find it: through an alley, behind the blackbird-painted door across from some dumpsters, and up a creaky wood staircase.

Press the buzzer outside Vancouver Hack Space (VHS) – a creative hub housing a regular assemblage of craft makers, computer nerds, amateur philosophers and more – and one of the members will turn a crank outside the second floor window, lowering the door key on a thin metal wire. Inside, the lights are controlled by red-green-blue sliders (which are wired to, and blink, when the toilet flushes, incidentally).

One member made their own 3D printer out of aluminum and plastic joiners sculpted on the lab's other 3D printer – that one made of plywood. I'm offered a mason jar of frothy home-brew as a member explains how VHS fits into a world-wide network of “hack spaces.” A large fibre-optic sign reads “BYTES,” a memento from the long-retired Science World cafe.

VHS is both a space and a community. Created several years ago as a creative social network, collective studio and maker-space, today it spans 60 paying members. It's beginning to outgrow the long, narrow room it's occupied for several years in the Downtown Eastside.

“It's like a brain gym,” says VHS member Emily Smith, “and is really a gem in Vancouver.

“However, I'm concerned that if spaces like this continue to get shut down . . . Vancouver will lose this vibrant, expanding community.”

Indeed, although VHS seems financially stable – possibly due to its fervent do-it-yourself ethos – other spaces like it are being pushed away: The Red Gate artist collective was evicted from its Hastings and Cambie three-story arts headquarters in October – and is still searching for a new space – and the Vancouver Community Lab is having to leave their Great Northern Way location later this year (525 Great Northern Way, Building 3, Unit 105).

Add to that the oft-mourned closure of the debt-riddled Vancouver Playhouse Theatre Company just shy of it's 50th birthday, and the departure of rising star dancer Joshua Beamish to New York, citing a lack of support, and you get a picture of a troubled arts community across all the disciplines.

Part of the problem, says Smith, who co-founded Vancouver's wildly successful Mini Maker Faire (June 23-24, PNE) – modelled after a similar event in San Francisco – is that the city's creative communities too rarely work together, cross-pollinate or even communicate with one another.

“A lot of these groups exist, they're just in marginalized spaces,” she explains. “They need more support – more visibility and more awareness of what they're doing. Rather than talk about a problem, I'm talking about solutions. This is what people are forced to do – to separate from their creative community and start their own communities and projects.”

More in Art

Varley in Vancouver, Part 1: The Group of 7 “bohemian” heads west

Group of Seven painter Frederick Varley lived in Vancouver and played a pivotal role in the creation of a West Coast art movement and sensibility.

Roselina Hung's exuberant creativity comes alive in "Myth and Men"

A Woman's View on "Myth and Men" at Initial Gallery. Roselina Hung's exhibition of exuberantly creative paintings.
"Main Barber from Sidewalk, 1968" Fred Herzog, courtesy Equinox Gallery

Visual art trailblazers honoured at the VIVA and Audain awards: Videos

Recipients of BC's most prestigious awards -- photographer Fred Herzog, performance artist Skeena Reece and painter Mina Totino -- explain the significance of winning awards.


Cost of rent and real estate in Van City ruinous

It is distressing  for the arts and for small businesses and non-profits who are trying to provide services and eke out a living in this city.

Organizations trying to run small cafes, art spaces, performing spaces or just sell some basic items in their neighbourhood can bearly or no longer afford to do so in what use to be known as one of the most progressive neighbourhoods in the country.

As gentrification explodes on the downtown east side and the Bob Rennies of this world buy up more and more land for "development", all the while keeping his eyes open for the Tate Modern, of course, further east  Commercial Drive is moving away from small family businesses and co ops to big business franchises and too expensive rents.  

City Hall, wake up--make Vancouver the most liveable and affordable green city in the world--before its too late! 

i lived in Van for a year and

i lived in Van for a year and it didnt really seem there was much going on. I wondered what happened to all the art students once they graduated. I studied in London then after my year back went to Berlin where i move between London and Berlin. There are huge opportunities here; you can make anything happen. Even if London is expensive there is so much open-ness to art.  I was thinking of a move to Van - getting away from the big city - but I am scared by the inertia and invisibility of the city's artistic energy.

I left...

I moved to Canada in the early 90's full of hope and optimism, and put in 20 years as a very active artist in Vancouver working with many arts organisations and doing solo work, as well as teaching workshops to other artists, with some success. However I have finally thrown in the towel and moved back to Europe. I haven't felt so excited in years. Unless Vancouver (both government and the general public) decides that art is worth supporting, I won't be back in a hurry. Not looking back...

ps... rent in England is half (seriously!) what I paid in Vancouver, and my food bill is a third (it really is!)... and I get paid higher fees for my artworks. Can't beat it, plus there is so much interest in the arts here from the public. I feel respected... just had to add that...  it makes a difference to feel that you are culturally valued.


gentrification ARGUMENT?

Rennie: "That gentrification argument went away long ago in Toronto"

"gentrification argument"? HAHAHAHA... oh right, it's an "argument"... hey, listen all you displaced arguers, go take your argument somewhere else 


canada goose jackets “You shall,” said Blandy, and he proceeded, with unctuous relish, to read the document As soon as she saw Elizabeth-Jane after her return indoors she told her that she had resolved to go away from home to the seaside for a few days--to Port-Bredy; Casterbridge was so gloomy moncler pas cher She on her part has promised to welcome no more addresses from you; and I trust, therefore, you will not attempt to force them upon her If it goes, that is all that matters to me hogan scarpe It may have been in the form of loans, but if not, it would rather look like blackmail No, no, I mean a proper calendar with the day of the week and the day of the month in good bold characters that I can read when I am sitting at the table hollister uk For my part I don't see why men who have got wives and don't want 'em, shouldn't get rid of 'em as these gipsy fellows do their old horses,"" said the man in the tent" The man’s name was given to us by Mr hollister " He looked towards Donald, who had come near “I have just put a few celluloid films in the bowl, and on the top one I have put a ring of this powder, which is a mixture of loaf sugar and chlorate of potash, both finely powdered and thoroughly stirred together chaussure louboutin pas cher OVER the events of the succeeding weeks I shall pass as lightly as possible “Is that correct?” he asked nobis outlet Everybody applauded the Mayor's proposed entertainment, especially when it became known that he meant to pay for it all himself I respect your vow That’s how they used to do ’em at Ur of the Chaldees when he was serving his time I was now clearly aware of what was going on around me, though too listless to take particular notice, lying still with my eyes closed or half-closed, in a state of utter exhaustion, with a sensation of sinking through the bed ’ “About half an hour, I should think canada goose jacket Henchard no longer required his help In presence of this scene after the other there was a natural instinct to abjure man as the blot on an otherwise kindly universe; till it was remembered that all terrestrial conditions were intermittent, and that mankind might some night be innocently sleeping when these quiet objects were raging loud They all had their uses, but it seemed to me that Mr "I don't altogether believe in forecasts, come to second thoughts on such canada goose jackets There was a short silence Don't go so fast, Stubberd, said the clerk


canada goose jackets I raised my head and received the full glare of the lantern in my face, which caused me instantly to close my eyes "That was your mother moncler pas cher I, also, inspected it, and saw at once that it was smaller than when I had left it; and I had no doubt that the ingenious Gus had “pinched” a portion of it for the purpose of making some private experiments As a matter of fact, this state of things was not so much owing to Stannidge the landlord's neglect, as from the lack of a painter in Casterbridge who would undertake to reproduce the features of men so traditional hogan outlet The woman looked on the ground, as if she maintained her position by a supreme effort of will Thorndyke smiled and Polton looked shocked hollister outlet Do you think he would let you make the change?” “Not at all,” replied Thorndyke hollister schweiz No crowd had yet collected, but just a handful of chance wayfarers like myself and a few policemen, who stood a little distance away from the house, looking on the scene of destruction and listening anxiously to the sounds of the approaching engines, now quite near and coming from several different directions Here’s a hansom coming in, so we shan’t have to fetch one But I made no remark; and, having obliterated the key-impressions with my thumb, I peeled the wax off the bench, squeezed it up into a lump, and put it into my bag The desire--sober and repressed--of Elizabeth-Jane's heart was indeed to see, to hear, and to understand Nobis Jackets Canada "Yes, sir Elizabeth, that silent observing woman, had long noted how he was rising in favour among the townspeople; and knowing Henchard's nature now she had feared that Farfrae's days as manager were numbered, so that the announcement gave her little surprise Nance accepted this offering thankfully at first; afterwards as a matter of course The room, itself crammed with highly inflammable material, seemed to have been expressly prepared for a fire “I followed the narrative with the closest attention, waiting for some definite discrepancy on which one could fasten But I tell you, young man, if this holds good for the bulk, as it has done for the sample, you have saved my credit, stranger though you be canada goose jackets That suit you?” ” woolrich Having said this, he sat down It was about six o'clock; the men were dropping off homeward one by one canada goose jacket ” The oft-quoted words were only too apposite in their application to the plans laid by poor Mr The old-fashioned fronts of these houses, which had older than old-fashioned backs, rose sheer from the pavement, into which the bow windows protruded like bastions, necessitating a pleasing chassez-dechassez movement to the time-pressed pedestrian at every few yards


louboutin pas cher But I'm very sorry! he said, in deprecating tones I've been a wife, and I've been a mother, and I never see such unprincipled bread in Casterbridge as this before nobis jackets At this moment the door of the mortuary opened to admit a newcomer, in whom we recognized a Dr During those moments Henchard had determined to follow up Lucetta notwithstanding her elusiveness, and he knocked for admission When he was calmer he turned to his original conviction that he must somehow find her and his little Elizabeth-Jane, and put up with the shame as best he could "That he is a hot-tempered man--a little proud--perhaps ambitious; but not a bad man No, he thought, Farfrae would be suggesting such improvements in his damned luminous way that in spite of himself he, Henchard, would sink to the position of second fiddle, and only scrape harmonies to his manager's talents canada goose jacket The day-wheel, driven by the clock, made a complete turn in twenty-four hours, and it carried the snail round with it I did not suggest that you killed him feloniously moncler pas cher He tore out the leaf, folded and directed it, and seemed about to throw it in through the open sash upon the dining-table; but, on second thoughts, edged himself through the loiterers, till he reached the door of the hotel, where one of the waiters who had been serving inside was now idly leaning against the doorpost You're no yoursel' the day? Donald inquired scarpe hogan A useful fellow! And the sooner you help somebody else in that way the better!"" Henchard continued his address to Jopp in similar terms till it ended in Jopp s dismissal there and then, Henchard turning upon his heel and leaving him" Then I turned homeward, if I may use the expression in connection with a hired bedroom, resolving to get a long night’s rest so as to be fresh for the beginning of my new labours in the morning hollister uk Well, then, I shall do it, he said, peremptorily “But there is one observation to make before finishing with the positive aspects of the case hollister online shop Now comes the point: Could she in honour dismiss the first?" A bad harvest, or the prospect of one, would double the price of corn in a few weeks; and the promise of a good yield would lower it as rapidly ” canada goose outlet The hardly-veiled hint that “it might be my concern” was not very comfortable to reflect on, but there was nothing to be done beyond keeping my tool-bag locked and the key in my pocket, which I was careful to do; and as the weeks passed, and nothing unusual happened, the affair gradually faded out of my mind Then Moxdale, knowing that he had been seen to enter the premises with Haire, and fearing that he would be accused of murder, decided to go to Dublin and personate Haire to make it appear that Haire was then alive woolrich Why--O what?"" She drew closer, and whispered in her mother's ear, ""Does he seem to you not likely to befriend us? I thought he looked a generous man" That’s the position canada goose sale When the young woman came in, sweetly unconscious of the turn in the tide, Lucetta went up to her, and said quite sincerely- It was plain that nothing so pathetic had been heard at the Three Mariners for a considerable time


canada goose outlet Abraham had never heard of an equatorial clock, all his experience having been in the ordinary trade While she was doing this the wood partition in the centre of the house thrilled to its centre with the tugging of a bellpull upstairs doudoune moncler Or again, he might have escaped from the bedroom and fallen down the stairs By the time we got into Billington Street we could see the chimney quite plain with lots of sparks flying out of it, so we hurried along until we came opposite the house, and then there was no mistake about it hogan outlet The lady seemed to warm towards her for that reply ” hollister outelt sale "What does that nonsense mean? You know I couldn't have helped myself if I had wished--that is, if I had any kindness at all It stood, with regard to the wide fertile land adjoining, clean-cut and distinct, like a chess-board on a green tablecloth hollister schweiz Abraham always took a watch down to clean it “But, my dear Polton,” I exclaimed chaussure louboutin pas cher But he still remained “I shall not contest your description, Jervis,” said the former, “but, in fact, the conclusion was practically a certainty Cheap Nobis Winter Jackets Sale She were rewarded by the Agricultural Society for having begot the greatest number of healthy children without parish assistance, and other virtuous marvels “As far as the calendar goes, sir, almost entirely All the gipsies and showmen who had remained on the ground lay snug within their carts and tents or wrapped in horse-cloths under them, and were silent and still as death, with the exception of an occasional snore that revealed their presence Are they gone--on the other side?" Its arrival created about as much sensation in the corn-market as a flying machine would create at Charing Cross The meaning of this was soon apparent canada goose jacket “You have accused a most respectable young man of a serious crime, and you have actually planted marked money on him and pretended that he stole it Thus did history repeat itself woolrich sito ufficiale Yes, sir; often, she said “I don’t know,” he said, slowly and with a considering air canada goose sale Thorndyke’s — which I have no doubt is supported by conclusive evidence — I, personally, accept it as true ”