A 16-year-old's testimony at Enbridge Northern Gateway JRP: "What the hell were you thinking?"

Video by Catherine Wallace

The following transcript is from the presentation of Sam Harrison, who presented at the Northern Gateway Joint Review Panel in Vancouver on January 31. 

"My name is Sam Harrison. From other people’s statements, I take it the norm is to list your credentials and the reasons why the Panel should listen to you in the first few sentences. Well, I don’t really have any. I’m 16 years old, halfway through high school, and the leader of a small group lobbying for action on climate change. That’s really about it."

"There is one really important reason I hope you will take what I have to say under advisement. I’m a kid. I’m part of the generation that will be left to clean up the mess left behind by my parents’ generation. We’re the ones who will have to inherit this world from you, so I hope you will listen carefully to why building a pipeline to export 82 million tonnes of carbon dioxide out of BC is a bad idea."

"It’s the 21st century and we’ve reached a pivotal point in human history. We simply can’t keep doing what we’re doing. There is no debate. Climate change is the issue of our time. It will define who we are and what our legacy will be for the rest of human civilization. We’re not living on the planet you were born into anymore. By the time I graduate university five years from now, it’s estimated that in the summer, the Arctic ice will be gone."

"We’ve taken one of the few features that makes planet earth what it is and as a species, we’ve broken it. By the time I have kids, it’s predicted crop yields in much of Africa will have fallen by as much as 25 percent, leaving millions to starve. The continent will be struck by international conflict, fighting over the few sources of fresh water and food that are left."

"By the time my future kids are graduating high school, almost half the species on earth will have gone extinct. If the melting Himalayan glaciers continue and they disappear, the 2 billion people that depend on them for fresh water will have to move. As of now, there are more refugees caused by climate change than by war. This is the planet you have left for us. Is that what you want your generation’s legacy to be?"

"Frankly, now much of the science is pointing to the fact that we can’t stop these things. The Arctic will melt; the world will experience the next mass extinction. My generation will have to deal with the consequences. Surely, your generation owes it to us to not make it worse."

"The International Energy Agency says we have five years to curb global greenhouse gas emissions. It may just be my youthful naiveté, but if that’s the case, expanding our network to extract, sell and burn fossil fuels seems highly impractical which brings us to another point." 

"People say, 'Well, if we don’t sell it, someone else will. We should sell it while we can and we’ll build the Canadian economy.' Frankly, that may be true. Maybe if we don’t sell it, someone else will, but that certainly doesn’t make it okay. I assure you, no parent ever has said to their kid, 'Don’t worry, it’s okayto become a drug dealer because if you don’t sell drugs, drug addicts will give their money to someone else. You should profit while you can.' That’s just wrong.”.

"Furthermore, they say it will grow the economy. Well, I have a message for you on behalf of youth all around the world. That is not the economy we want for our future. We simply cannot keep investing in fossil fuel infrastructure. The Enbridge pipeline would export the equivalent of 82 mega tonnes of CO2 per year. That’s more than B.C. emits as an entire province."

"We have quite some progressive policies in place in the B.C. government and allowing this project to go through our province will be going in the exact wrong direction. We need to drastically reduce emissions and becoming a carbon superhighway to the Pacific is not the way to do it. Regardless of where the oil is burned, it will have the same effect on all 7 billion of us."

"Canadians are supposed to be the nicest people on earth. That’s one of the stereotypes I actually like about us, but we can’t be if our entire economy is based on selling fossil fuels. It’s time we draw a line in the sand."

"This is why I’ve spent my high school career not partying and hanging out with friends, but advocating for political change because I know, even if we don’t stop this project, some day when I have kids and they look me in the eyes and ask, “What the hell were you thinking, why didn’t you do anything about this” I know I’ll be able to look them back in the eyes with absolute confidence and say, “I’m sorry. I tried my very hardest”.

"Will you? Please don’t let this pipeline go through."

For more information about the pipeline proposal, JRP hearings and climate change, read Extract: The Pipeline Wars Vol. 1 Enbridge published by the Vancouver Observer.

More in Earth Matters

What to do when the IPCC gets you down

There's only so much end of the world you can take. Here's what you can do about it.

Learning the language of climate solutions

If someone had told me how hard learning another language was I wouldn't have tried.

Failure not an option for climate movement

Saying the climate movement is a failure and we should give up is not an option.
Speak up about this article on Facebook or Twitter. Do this by liking Vancouver Observer on Facebook or following us @Vanobserver on Twitter. We'd love to hear from you.

Sam Harrison

Thank you Sam for a spectacular presentation on behalf of all of us who agree with you completely. The future just got brighter for me, listening to you. Thank you very much. Jef Simpson

enbridge pipeline

I also want to express my appriciation and heartfelt Thanks to you, taking away some of my concerns of our troubled future.

One is never too young and too old to fight for our environment, human rights and a sustain our wilderness that is so fragile.


Being able to say we tried.

My husband and I are in our sixties and this is the reason we were arrested in Washington. We have three lovely grandchidren, and whatever hell they face with their children in the future, we wanted them to know that 'we tried'. When we went, we didn't think it would make much difference, but the Keystone still hasn't been okayed.......a lot more people have come out against it, and even if it goes through, the fight against it is building an army of climate activists. Good for you young man..........and be assured. some of the grandparents are with you, and more will be coming on side every day, especially with elequent young people like you urging us, like Moses, to be part of a promised future we won't get to see. We can transition.and we can live sustainably on this earth. What's more, we have to.

Kudos to Sam

Well Sam Harrison, kudos to you. You have said what needs to be shouted from the roof tops. I am 61 years old. I live in Ontario and never in my life, in the Canada that I grew up in have I seen such an obnoxious disregard for our natural world and disrespect for our environment. I hope that Sam and his generation when they turn voting age rise up and hold accountable these people who seek to destroy a livable climate just so they can line their pockets with money stolen from generations which follow.  

Change will never come from those in my generation who long ago sold out to the almighty buck comfortable in the knowledge that any price which is eventually extracted won't be their problem. There are few words in the English language that adequately describe the utter contempt the government of Canada has for facts, science, our environment and the living creatures that we share this Earth with. We are ruled by deeply evil men and until people rise up and demand action the situation will only become more dire.


The real world

we live in a capitolist society. if it makes economic sense to pull a resource out of the ground, it will be done. why? cos people will pay for it. When people (thats like u and me and little sammy there) stop buying whatever they are selling it will stop. 

in the meantime the stuff will come out of the ground, and if its not piped, then it will be trucked (resulting in more damage to the environment).

This was absolutely painful

This was absolutely painful to read.  It will serve him well to attend post-secondary and learn how to refer to scientific research and sources instead of pulling stats out of nowhere.  He nailed it with the "I'm just a kid and may be naive" part.  The Engbridge Pipeline will create thousands of Canadian jobs.