'Clean' LNG would produce large-scale emissions

BC Premier Christy Clark has repeatedly promised the world's cleanest LNG industry. But what would that look like when the projects are underway? 

BC Premier Christy Clark at LNG conference in Vancouver this week. The Premier told conference participants that LNG is the "greenest fossil fuel" in the world, but studies paint a different picture. Photo by Mychaylo Prystupa.
While British Columbia's government and proponents of the liquefied natural gas industry are promoting the nascent industry as the cleanest in the world, the figures contained in export permit licences approved so far indicate the industry could produce emissions two-thirds those of Alberta's oil sands.

"If we don't ask all the (proponents) to reduce their carbon footprint of British Columbia with what they propose, we'll be nearly equal to the oil sands and that's unacceptable to the people of British Columbia," said Merran Smith, director of Clean Energy Canada at Tides Canada.

A dozen-plus plants are proposed for the province's coast. Gas would come primarily from the province's northeast. Some of it is bound for Oregon. Nine BC proposals have already been granted export permit licences by the National Energy Board and, along with pipeline proposals to move gas from the northeast's gas fields, are in various phases of the approvals process, including environmental assessments.

A September 2013 report from Clean Energy Canada said BC has promised the world's cleanest LNG industry. It's a drum Premier Christy Clark has thumped repeatedly.

What Clean Energy Canada found, though, in a
study of two BC proposed plants and technologies is that emissions would be triple that of plants in Australia and Norway.

The study looked at data from wellhead to shipment. It found Norwegian plants produced between 0.35 and 0.36 metric tons of greenhouse gas emissions for each metric ton of LNG produced.

The report found a BC facility using similar technology would produce 0.96 metric tons of emissions for each ton of gas produced.

On March 11 , BC's Environmental Assessment Office ordered a comment period for the assessment of the BG Group's Prince Rupert LNG.

Canada's National Energy Board Dec. 16 approved a 25-year export permit application for Prince Rupert LNG for an annual volume of 21 million metric tons of LNG.

And what do the other plants export permits approve? Here's a list: 

• Woodfibre LNG - 1.2 million metric tons;
• WCC LNG - 30 million metric tons;
• Pacific NorthWest LNG - 19.6 million metric tons;
• BC LNG - 1.8 million metric tons;
• Kitimat LNG - 10 million metric tons;
• LNG Canada - 24 million metric tons;
• Aurora LNG - 24 million metric tons;
• Triton - 2.3 million metric tons; and,
• Prince Rupert - LNG 21.6 metric tons.

That's 134.5 million metric tons annually for one proposed industry with plants approved for export licences thus far. 
Multiply that by .96 for the emissions figure arrived at by Clean Energy Canada and you get 129.12 million metric tons of emissions annually - or 12.9 megatonnes.

According to Alberta Energy, 2010 statistics for Alberta's oilsands indicate mining and upgrading facilities accounted for 28.1 megatonnes while 19 oil sands in-situ facilities accounted for 18.7 megatonnes.

More from Jeremy Hainsworth

See more

More in News

“Freedom for Iran”: rally in Vancouver urges Canada to support protesters in Iran

"This is the rise of the poor in the cities and the countryside, the rise of women and youth who have nothing to lose,” shouted one protester as dozens gathered on a cold, rainy Saturday in Vancouver...

Will the National Housing Strategy cool Vancouver house prices? No one thinks so.

Waiting for the bubble to burst? You may be waiting a long, long time, because...

Respected Elder of the Tsleil-Waututh Nation Leonard George

It is with great sadness we announce the passing of Tsleil-Waututh Nation respected Elder Leonard George. We express our deepest gratitude to the George Family, the Tsleil-Waututh Nation and everyone...
Speak up about this article on Facebook or Twitter. Do this by liking Vancouver Observer on Facebook or following us @Vanobserver on Twitter. We'd love to hear from you.