In open letter to the Premier, APPLE BC says education promise is 'totally unrealistic'
Dear Premier Campbell:
Before you depart as Premier of British Columbia we, the members of APPLE BC, a newly-formed alliance of parents and partners, would like to send an open letter to you stating our position on the ongoing underfunding of K-12 public education in this province.
This letter is also directed at your successor, so that the issues raised are appropriately dealt with.
We view with the strongest reservations the commitment you made during a province-wide television address, on Wednesday October 27, 2010, to parents that all Grade 4 students in British Columbia would be reading and writing at a Grade 4 level within the next 5 years.
Given the fact your government has been in power for the past decade and that our public schools have been underfunded over that time, and given the fact that you did not provide any information about funding levels for your ambitious goal for our students, we would like to itemize for you, and your successor, the full implications of the solemn commitment you made, as well as our detailed reservations on your promise.
It should be noted that in a poll commissioned by the BC Society for Public Education and conducted by Angus Reid that almost 80% of members of the general public wanted more money for public schools.
We have selected one board - namely, the Vancouver Board of Education, for a review and a call for reinstatement of the programs and services needed in our city schools, at both the district and board level, in order to fully implement your goal. You noted that this would be an "expensive” undertaking but provided no outline of costs involved or of the financial commitment your government was prepared to make to achieve this goal.
We have undertaken in this open letter to outline the scope of the task that lies ahead for your successor. In the 16 itemized points that follow, we show the implications for our urban school district and the obstacles that have to be overcome to even begin to achieve this end.
1. Elimination of the VSB’S funding shortfalls over the next two years
Already our board has gone through a wrenching experience, eliminating $17.3 million from last year’s VSB budget. The anticipated shortfalls for the next two years are as follows: $9.6 million for the 2011-2012 school year and $5.17 million for the 2012-2013 school year. (Since the 2002-2003 school year, the Vancouver board has lost $68 million in cumulative cuts). It is essential that these shortfalls be eliminated by the province before any other restoration of services is contemplated. Otherwise, the cascading effect of ongoing and continuous cutbacks- a fact of life for our board over the past ten years-- will continue unabated through the system.
And please do not send us another “special adviser" in the form of the provincial Comptroller General, with her $200,000 report, to inform us that the VSB has a “large surplus”. Even government supporters on the board have deemed this a “preposterous assessment".
2. Restoration of VSB’s Inner City Early Childhood (junior kindergarten) programs
The elimination of early childhood programs for 4-year-old students in three Vancouver inner city schools (Strathcona, Seymour and Queen Alexandra) must be rectified. These long-standing, twenty-year programs, absurdly deemed ‘non–core’ by the ministry officials, were part of a genuine strong start for some of the poorest children in this city. The only junior kindergartens left in Vancouver are now found in private schools. It is ironic that these classes are eliminated at a time when early childhood education is supposedly a focus for your government.
3. Restoration of primary (Grades 1-3) ESL reception classes