MovieDate_600.jpg

An Education Gets Mixed Reviews

Carey Mulligan and Peter Sarsgaard in An Education.

Robert’s Rating: Thumbs down 

Conflicted. I don’t know what happened. I was thoroughly enjoying so many aspects of this film; the excellent acting of the female lead, the authentic feel of the Sixties art direction; the beautiful composition of the images, and the delightful story about the coming of age of a precocious schoolgirl. Yes, the smarmy seduction of a young girl by an older man was a bit hard to watch but since it was the central thread of the plot I was willing to go along for the ride. But a half an hour from the end the film just lost me. The meticulous revelation of a delicate story suddenly became a predictable succession of Disney clichés. It felt like some staff writer was brought in to tidy up the loose ends of a film that had, up to that point, successfully mirrored the messiness of life. I say skip this cut and pray there’s an alternate ending on the DVD. 

Karen’s Rating: Thumbs up 

While it wasn’t the brilliant piece film that some reviewers claimed, it was a thoroughly enjoyable and engaging film. As Robert notes, the visuals alone make this film worth seeing. A faithful and charming recreation of the 60s in working class Britain. You are transported to the era where the choices for women were limited to teaching or marriage, and our young heroine falls into a tragic trap while struggling to create a more interesting future for herself. The plot carries us along, and while we know something is awry, the truth that is unveiled still manages to take us by surprise. Up and coming actress Carey Mulligan gives a stunning performance as a powerful yet vulnerable young woman who manages to keep her dignity intact, giving a new kind twist to this oldest of stories. Worth the watch. And besides, if you wait for the DVD, the popcorn is just never as good at home.

More in Karen and Robert's Movie Date

Crazy Heart: Thumbs Up or Thumbs Down?

Do Karen and Robert give this film a pass? (Read more)

Karen and Robert Discover The Invention of Lying

Karen – Thumbs Up.  I laughed and laughed and laughed some more. I had to try and stop laughing because I was so loud and I didn’t want my neighbours to throw their popcorn at me. Now...

Jane Campion's Bright Star Gets Movie Date's Top Rating

Robert’s rating:  Thumbs up. Poetic.  Ahh, 1818.  An exquisite year for the characters in Bright Star and masterfully rendered both visually and atmospherically for the audience by...
Speak up about this article on Facebook or Twitter. Do this by liking Vancouver Observer on Facebook or following us @Vanobserver on Twitter. We'd love to hear from you.