mma musings copy.jpg

GSP vs. Anderson Silva super fight

Not an insignificant size difference between GSP (L) and Anderson Silva. Photo courtesy Georgessaintpierre.com

Since UFC 154 and George 'Rush' St. Pierre’s dominant decision win over Carlos Condit, rumours have swirled like a twister in the courtyard over a super fight between the welterweight champion and middleweight kingpin and #1 pound for pound fighter Anderson 'The Spider' Silva.

Anderson Silva has been pining for the match up for some time, and might be getting desperate since his ultimate retirement looms.  He has nothing left to prove other than fighting GSP, the #2 pound for pound MMA fighter. While almost all fans and pundits pick the much longer limbed, larger Silva to win, GSP poses significant risks for the Brazilian.

If a heavier fighter challenges a lighter fighter, it should be incumbent upon the former to move to the latter’s weight class. Silva walks around at 215-220 pounds, but he fought at 168 in PRIDE. It’s unclear whether or not Silva could cut an extra 7-8 pounds today if they fought at a catch weight of 177-178. GSP’s walk around weight is only about 187, so many fans feel Silva needs to make this concession.

Former welterweight champion Matt Hughes came up with an interesting point, suggesting GSP has a legit shot at beating Silva. GSP’s unrivalled transition from striking to takedowns, Hughes says, poses significant problems for Silva, who has shown susceptibility to takedowns by good wrestlers. Even with his long limbs and ability to defend off his back, Silva may be doing that the entire fight.

Hughes therefore suggests the fight take place at 185 and that Silva put his belt on the line.  No word yet on Silva’s opinion on Hughes’ take, but Silva doesn’t seem apt to take risks at this stage of his career: he’s kyboshed suggestions that he move up and fight Jon 'Bones' Jones for the 205 pound belt, even though Silva has fought and won three bouts at this weight class, all KO/TKOs. GSP has never fought at 185.

Odds are Silva wins a super fight v. GSP via KO in the second or third, after finally thwarting a takedown. The benefit for GSP is that he really doesn’t stand to lose much street cred with a loss: Silva’s already ranked #1 pound for pound, GSP #2; Silva is so dominant at 185 and so much bigger than GSP---25-30 pounds---that it won’t reflect poorly on the Canadian’s rep at 170; GSP would be doing something Silva is not willing to do, namely fight the champion of the next weight class up.

I’d like to see GSP bargain for one more chip: have him sign the deal v. Silva if Silva inks to fight Jon Jones.

Follow me on Twitter @RenkoStyranka

 

 

More in MMA Musings

Another high profile UFC veteran quits Dana White

Another high-profile UFC fighter quits Dana White.

UFC on Fox 12: Robbie Lawler defeats Matt Brown

Robbie Lawler wins a brawl over Matt Brown and a rematch against welterweight champion Jonny Hendricks.

UFC 175: Chris Weidman defeats Lyoto Machida

A champion and a former champion make each other dig deep in this stellar middleweight title match.
Speak up about this article on Facebook or Twitter. Do this by liking Vancouver Observer on Facebook or following us @Vanobserver on Twitter. We'd love to hear from you.

GSP at 185? definitely not...

They should fight at no more than 175, just like Hughes vs. Gracie. It is much harder to gain weight than to lose it IMO. We're not talking about fat here! Big difference. I don't see Silva risking cutting more than 20-25 pounds for the weigh ins, so he'de have to be a lean 195-200 fight night. If GSP could manage to gain a solid 5 pounds of muscle, he'de be around 190 fight night. 5-10 pounds is alot, especially when the smaller guy is relying on wresting skills! I'de love to see it. What a win it would be for GSP if he somehow pulled it off! After that I wanna see Frankie Edgar vs. Bob Sap...

for a co-main event, Hendricks vs. Nick Diaz

Nick Diaz vs. Johnny Hendricks would be a great co-main event in my opinion. They both deserve to be thrown this bone. I watched the Condit Diaz fight again and he actually won round 1, 2 & 5! First time I watched it, I agreed with the judges. weird.