Skip to Content

Sports Couple

Sports Couple 640x140.png

The Case: For and against the Carson Palmer trade

Nolan KellyShane Vajda
Oct 20th, 2011

NOLAN: FOR

The Raiders are taking a lot of flak for the price they paid (first and second round draft picks). Don’t let anyone fool you into thinking its two firsts (Shane) – the second rounder becomes a first if Oakland makes it to the AFC championship, and that means they win the trade outright.

Why I like this trade: the Raiders will probably pick somewhere in the 18-24 neighbourhood this April. 1/3 of picks from 18-24 in the last 10 years are pro bowlers, 1/3 are average NFLers and 1/3 are busts. Considering how easy it is to acquire an average NFL player, it’s the 1/3 pro bowlers that matter. The odds of drafting a pro-bowler drastically decrease in the second round.

Carson Palmer means, at 4-2, the Raiders season is not a write off anymore. It means they have a very realistic shot of winning the AFC West. The Raiders win by running the ball. Carson Palmer throws a nice deep pass. Those two attributes should complement each other nicely, and will keep defences honest.

And with two solid successive drafts in 2010 and 2011, the Raiders are stocked with young talent.

The Case: for and against the new BC Place roof

Nolan KellyShane Vajda
Sep 28th, 2011

An aerial rendering of the new roof.

SHANE: FOR

No question – BC Place was in drastic need of an upgrade. Drab would be an apt description of the stadium. BC Place was state of the art in when it opened in 1983...but so were DeLoreans and Sony Walkmans. 

And Vancouverites might just be a little jealous of how Seattle tore down the Kingdome and got two beautiful stadiums as a result. So we need a new stadium? Great. Where are you going to put it?

You have to put it downtown. Downtown is the only place that makes any sense. You can’t have it in Burnaby or the near PNE – the local residents can barely stand the traffic caused by events at the PNE and Coliseum respectively. Putting the stadium out in Surrey or the Maple Ridge area kills any walk-up sales you intend on getting (which for the Lions, can be a considerable portion of the crowd) so the stadium needs to be somewhere downtown. In case you haven’t noticed, there's not a whole lot of room in downtown Vancouver anymore. If you look up you’ll see highrise buildings. Everywhere. Lots of people live there. Some of those people can even walk to BC Place to see a game.

Syndicate content