Skip to Content
blogheader_linda_final_large.jpg

What really happened outside the Fairmont Hotel at the G8 University Summit protest?

Read More:
« prevnext »

Photo by Murray Bush-Flux  from the Vancouver Media Coop website. Go to Vancouver Media Coop for extensive photographs from the demonstration and their view of what happened. Click here to read police press release.

Six arrested at G8 summit. Combing through Google, after typing in "protesters arrested G8 university summit," I find a page full of headlines that continues on to the next page. The news sources differ, but the headline is identical, from CBC to The Province. The press release that inspired the stories originated from the bland headline: "Protest in Downtown Vancouver", sent out by email to press organizations across Canada from Constable Jana McGuiness of the Vancouver Police Department. 

"What began as a peaceful protest Friday afternoon ended with three men and three women being taken into custody by Vancouver Police after protesters tried to storm (my emphasis) the Fairmont Waterfront Hotel located at 900 Canada Place Way, in opposition to a meeting taking place inside," it read.

Like the other news organizations in Vancouver and throughout Canada, I posted the press release and tagged it "press release", then I posted links on Facebook and Twitter. Instantly, I got a reply on Twitter: "Is this a press release from the police?"   I tweeted a message, asking if anyone had a more complete picture of what happened. Then I found the video CTV posted, documenting the disturbing encounter.

Thanks to a Facebook contact, I got in touch with Harsha Wallia, an eyewitness and participant in the protest. Wallia says she's in her late 20s and who describes herself simply as a "local activist". I asked her what happened. What were the protesters demonstrating for? What did they want to accomplish? What motivated them to get out in the streets and confront the police? The first thing she said was that demonstrators never tried to gain access to the hotel. So, what really happened, she said, was this.

The march began at 3 p.m. Friday afternoon and continued until 6 or 7 p.m., she said. 80 to 100 people had organized themselves in opposition to the G8 University Summit that was taking place at the Fairmont Hotel on Burrard. The G8 Summit in Toronto in June is the meeting of the heads of state, Wallia explained. The G8 University Summit was called, in the protester's view, "to talk about the ways in which universities can continue to privatize."

To the protesters the summit's agenda seemed aimed at deteriorating public education. In their view, the meeting was less about making education accessible and more about "shifting the burden more onto the shoulders of students through debt, and partnering with some of the world's biggest corporations, many of whom have  atrocious human rights and social records, like pharmaceuticals and defense companies, and mining corporations that have devastating environmental records," Wallia said.

"When you break down the summit, it's knocking out a path of neo-Liberalism and inaccessibility to pursue education."

The Vancouver Courier previewed the meeting. "Presidents of world universities gather in Vancouver today and tomorrow (May 21 and 22) to prepare advice for their governments as Canada gets ready to host the G8 Summit in Huntsville, Ont. next month. The summit, held at the Fairmont Pacific Rim hotel, is co-hosted by the University of B.C. and the University of Alberta. It's the third G8 University Summit and the first to be held in North America," an unsigned article reported. It also quoted a news release from UBC president Stephen Toope. "Our G8 University Summit offers a chance to show that universities can be effective agents for change and that we have solutions to help communities all over the world take action to ensure a sustainable future," said Toope.

 "It was a handpicked group of students and politicians, presidents of universities.

(6) Comments

BobbieBees May 22nd 2010 | 7:19 PM
I haven't trusted the police in a very long time. After they botched up the investigation into my mugging in '95, and my subsequent experience with 'the thin blue line', I have to to realize that the police are not there to protect you and I. They are there solely to keep us inder control and to protect the rich and elite. After what happened out at UBC with Sgt. Pepper and subsequent police actions not only in this city, but around the world, it should become very obvious that the police are veering away from being public servants, to being protectors of the rich and elite. Remember the infamous 'riot' at the start of the Olympics where a bunch of 'protestors' smashed up the windows at the Bay on Granville and Georgia. Well after seeing how the Surete du Quebec tried to incite a riot at the Montebello Summit, I can only believe that the reason why the 200 cops in riot gear that were surrounding the 'protestors' were unable to make an arrest, is you can't arrest agent provocatuers.
Joseph Jones May 22nd 2010 | 10:22 PM
The VO retailing of police department propaganda was disappointing. With this story, you have taken a step toward redeeming VO by putting out semi-mainstream coverage that contradicts egregious and widespread chain-reaction hearsay. Harsha Walia is correct: there was no attempt whatsoever to storm the Fairmont. The discrepancy between what the police say and what actually happened would startle any bystanding observer – and does no credit to our local forces of law and order. The more you know about this incident, the uglier it looks.
I appreciate hearing the perspective of one of the protesters, since I think the issue of university support for neoliberalism is what needs to be addressed. Thanks to the protest, issues like privatization of public education get more attention, but I also think that Friday’s protest of the G8 University Summit sent a confusing message, which I think may divide more than unite the public with those critical of the current political and economic arrangement. This stems more from the protest design than it does from the Vancouver Police, the traditional media or the G8 University Summit itself. If our agenda is to build power to end poverty and replace the current system with a just and fair alternative, then I think we should consider rethinking how we communicate our vision. I wrote my own criticism of the protest at http://tomkertes.com/1723.
linda's picture
linda May 23rd 2010 | 9:09 AM

Fair enough, Joe.  I definitely should have waited until I could talk with people who were there.   I'm glad I found my way to Harsha and would welcome hearing from more people who were there.  I'm right here at my desk much of the time and the best way to make sure the story gets out in the right way on VO is to call me and let me know what went down, send me pictures, etc.  Unfortunately, I don't always know these things are happening as they're happening.  I will always try to tell as many sides of the story as there are and as I have access to. 

I agree that privatization of universities is a problem, with too much corporate research, too little provincial funding. Still, I can't find evidence that the G8 University Summit was a meeting to promote privatization. Is there any? The group's website seems to suggest it was pretty harmless - a bunch of university types, largely from Japan, all agreeing that environmental sustainability is a good thing, and to work together on programs that support that. http://g8u-summit.jp/english/index.html I agree with Tom Kertes analysis. Maybe there were things to protest: the secrecy, maybe the waste of money on motherhood stuff, that these universities do too much corporate research and there was no evidence they'll cut back, the lack of grassroots participation, etc. But privatization? It seems to me protest has to have a realistic focus, or the message coming out with inevitably will be "protesters clash with police"... and nothing more.
kerehzee May 30th 2010 | 2:14 PM
so, funny aspect to this part of the whole day. the delegates were done for the day, and were getting on a bus to go to a dinner. 1 protestor luckily enough spotted the bus in behind the hotel and voila! instant chaos. did i mention that day's discussion was about sustainability? i'm all for free speech, but maybe social change works better when you take it straight to the voter themselves. social networking's gotta be more effective than getting jailed for protesting people going for dinner.