Skip to Content

The Fever To Vaccinate Part II - Slipping You The Needle

Read More:

I’ve heard 2 stories this week of people going to see their doctor about something totally unrelated to seasonal influenza and without any discussion or request, suddenly having a needle thrust at them.  One woman was so surprised, the needle was in her arm before she could even ask what it was for.  Her doctor’s reply after the syringe was out? “It’s for the H1N1.  You work with people, you should have this shot.”  What she didn’t tell my friend was that her ulcerative colitis symptoms could consequently go through the roof, as the adjuvant in the vaccine (squalene, an ingredient in the anthrax vaccine implicated in  the Gulf War Syndrome as per a blind study done at Tulane University in 2000 – go to http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10640454) or the preservative (thimerisol, a type of mercury which has had no toxicity studies specifically done on its long-term actions within the human body) could trigger or exacerbate auto-immune disorders.  Clueless as to why her ulcerative colitis symptoms suddenly became much worse, she was then prescribed a heavy dose of steroids to calm the inflammation down – one drug just seems to lead to another.   

 

In the other story, the woman was taking her elderly father to see the doctor.  Again without any request on her part or inquiry by the doctor, a tray suddenly appeared with not just one needle (presumably for the father who was the patient), but two!  Fortunately the woman, who is a nurse and alert to the unexplained presence of needles, immediately demanded to know what these were for and vehemently declined the one targeted for her.  When the doctor turned his back for a moment, she signaled to her father to decline as well, which he did.  As a 92 year old man, his risk of the H1N1 is minimal - most people over the age of 65 developed natural immunity to a similar virus strain which circulated years ago.  As he is currently awaiting hip replacement surgery and subject to constant pain, the added stress on his body from the vaccine itself could have had a serious impact.

 

So what’s this about – we’ve gone from media stories of long line-ups of people waiting for the H1N1 vaccine, to it now being forced upon anyone showing up at their doctor’s for an office visit?  What if these people have already had H1N1 and developed life-long immunity?  What if these people had already been vaccinated at a walk-in clinic?  What if these people currently have some other condition or illness (which would be likely for most people visiting a doctor) and shouldn’t have the added stress of a vaccine imposed upon their already burdened immune system?  These doctors didn’t even inquire, but seem to be under the order to vaccinate first, respond to questions later.  All this at the time when more and more stories are coming from doctors and even elected officials in other countries, declaring the whole H1N1 pandemic to be wildly over-stated and the vaccine to be nothing more than an experiment with no long-term testing behind it to validate either its effectiveness or safety. 

 

In my own practice, I have treated many different kinds of flus and colds this fall, none of them serious but with such a broad spectrum of symptoms that it’s hard to believe they all were caused by the same virus.  In the majority of cases, the right homeopathic remedy has quickly sent them on the road to recovery but each case has had to be looked at individually – there has been no one remedy which has fit the majority of cases.  For clients who have learned a bit of homeopathy and have a kit of remedies at home, they have often been able to treat themselves or their family on the spot – and when in doubt, a phone call to me has been an effective back-up plan.  How much more empowering to be able to help yourself or loved one immediately and safely in an acute illness!  How much more reassuring to work with a  system that supports rather than confuses the immune system’s actions, and works to leave the person strengthened as a result.  While our conventional medical system works wonders, it’s not the only alternative out there for health care and in some cases its treatments appear to actually weaken our overall vitality.

 

For those people who do feel their health has suffered since receiving the vaccine, you are not alone.  Except for the inflammation around the injection site itself, some side effects don’t show up right away and may seem unrelated to the vaccination, so good luck getting a medical professional to acknowledge there could be a link.  Dating back to the inception of the smallpox vaccine in the 1800’s, homeopaths have been helping thousands of people recover from the damage of “vaccinosis” which in many cases caused serious illness or even death.  If you have had the H1N1 vaccine and find you have been sick or experienced an increase in any chronic illness symptoms, consider that it might have something to do with your body’s difficult response to the vaccine.  So before you let anyone slip you the needle, remember that sometimes the cure is worse than the disease.

(3) Comments

Login / Register to post new comment.
By Abber
Dec 11th, 2009
4:16 PM

Dangerous article

Vaccines are preventative medicines that offer the greatest benefit at the lowest risk. One of the biggest dangers we face right now is from those who spread misinformation about them and thereby encourage the population to go unvaccinated, which could result in their suffering illness and death from preventable diseases. And I cannot believe that any doctor would simply stab a needle into a patient's arm without their consent and knowledge of what it was. If the story is true, it is a serious case of malpractice. Unfortunately you have taken two isolated incidents (if true) and used them as ammunition with which to scare people away from vaccinations, which could in itself be considered malpractice.

If you think the H1N1 vaccine is inadequately tested, you are way off the mark. As with all (conventional) medicines, it has been rigorously tested and is actually well targeted to the H1N1 virus. However, since you put so much emphasis on testing, how about testing your own magic water solutions, otherwise known as homeopathy? All scientific tests have shown them to be no better than placebos; as drugs they simply do not work.

So let us take a closer look at some more of your fear-mongering: You bring up the preservative Thimerosal, but you offer no argument that it is harmful; you merely suggest that studies on it have not been sufficiently long for your liking. Thimerosal used to be a favourite amongst anti-vaccinationists, who claimed it caused autism in children. However when its use in childrens' scheduled vaccines was discontinued about a decade ago and no changes in autism rates occurred, as they predicted it would, that line of argument fell out of favour.

Your squalene argument came with supporting evidence, so I looked up the reference you gave. The results presented in the paper were vague and far from conclusive and, in fact, they made no suggestion that the Gulf War vaccines actually contained any squalene. A later study found no evidence for the use of squalene in those vaccines. The research continued and a paper published this year concluded: "We found no association between squalene antibody status and chronic multisymptom illness (p=0.465). The etiology of Gulf War syndrome remains unknown, but should not include squalene antibody status.". And further studies have shown that most adults have antisqualene antibodies at levels that are not increased by the use of the squalene adjuvant in vaccines. Squalene is naturally occurring and is absorbed into the body through diet.

It is easy to cite research when it appears to back your arguments, but if you're going to rely upon the scientific evidence, you cannot ignore the results when they don't support your agenda. Your fear-mongering arguments appear to lack substance, a bit like homeopathic drugs lack any active ingredients or any evidence that they even work.



------------

Some recommended reading for those who prefer evidence that their medicines work, rather than anecdotes that someone's headache went away one day after consuming magic sugar pills: http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?p=851

Also see Amy Wallace's article in Wired magazine, which does a very good job of confronting anti-vaccinationist arguments and describing how these groups, who are idealogically opposed to vaccines, are putting peoples' lives at risk: http://www.wired.com/magazine/2009/10/ff_waronscience/all/

By Olivia Fermi
Jan 12th, 2010
11:23 PM

Vaccines are Helpful

I don't want to comment on the efficacy of homeopathy. I believe there are folks for whom the H1N1 vaccine is not appropriate! And they are the exceptions, the minority.

I do want to thank the previous commenter for thoroughly and lucidly rebutting the idea we should avoid vaccines. I also agree if a doctor gives any medication including an injection - without the patient's consent - there is a serious problem - but this problem is not logically related to the efficacy/safety of H1N1 vaccines, any other vaccine or medication - it's a problem with the doctor.

Personally, I was grateful to be able to get both H1N! and the regular flu vaccines. Some of my friends who didn't, ended up very ill with H1N1, and it was pretty awful for them until they recovered. All I had was a small section of one arm slightly sore for a few days.

An acquaintene of mine refused to have herself or her children vaccinated. Then she complained about the lack of resources at VGH when her children got H1N1 and she had to take them to the emergency room with dangerously high fevers. Quietly inside my own mind, I was shocked that she had been so irresponsible not to have vaccinated her children. And that she didn't seem to realize her decision affects all of us. Getting vaccines is a way to help our medical system - a way to use the limited resources we have more efficiently so Emergency Services are available for the kinds of emergencies which couldn't have been prevented with a shot in the arm.

By Greg8160
Mar 13th, 2010
12:00 AM

Healthy adults didn't have vaccinations as kids!

Twenty one years ago, when my kids were babies, there was little information available on the harmful effects of vaccinations. We read what we could find on both sides of the issue, and decided not to use vaccinations at all.

Now our kids are happy, healthy adults, and although one of them decided to have tetanus vaccination, they are happy they didn't have all those unnecessary, strange cells and preservatives injected into their bloodstream.

We have found that being as close to nature as possible works best for us, and we are glad to see there is now a wealth of information available on the web and in books for both sides in this serious debate, so people can read it and decide for themselves.

Greg
www.minimum.com